This is a guest post by Nathan Roth, a New York lawyer writing under a pseudonym.
Despite the enormous attention given to the proposed Islamic Center at Ground Zero, I think an essential issue - perhaps the issue - has been missed. Many people object to the location not because they are bigots or Islamphobes, but because the decision to site it there is “insensitive.” This is the word of the day, and has become the proxy for unexplained sentiments that cause people who otherwise embrace religious freedom and pluralism just to shake their heads when it comes to Imam Rauf’s project.
Continue reading ‘Message to Imam Rauf: The Battle is Within Islam’
[Y]ou might draw two conclusions about the various groups and individuals who’ve tried to hijack the commemoration. Firstly, that they regard themselves as the bearers of truths which the rest of us are too deadened or complacent to realize, as anyone who has condemned himself to a session surfing wingnut websites knows painfully. Secondly, that the camps which promote these truths are mutually exclusive; you cannot both fulminate against the “Islamization” of America and insist that 9/11 was a message to U.S. imperialism that its chickens had come home to roost. You cannot - to transpose this theme to the motley crew of misfits gathering with their slogans in Lower Manhattan - be Pamela Geller and George Galloway.
Or can you?
From my latest piece which you can find on The Propagandist. I’d like to record, here, my gratitude to Adam Holland, whose superb dispatches helped crystallize my thoughts. Of course, I’m responsible for the argument, not Adam.

Richard Falk, who carries a UN Mandate to write reports based solely on testimony from people who loathe Israel, has given an interview to the “Democracy Now!” show in the aftermath of his expulsion from Israel.
Continue reading ‘Richard Falk: I Was Misunderstood’

There will be much - some might say too much - commentary today, the seventh anniversary of the atrocities of September 11, 2001.
Continue reading ‘Seven Years On’